# Copywriting Arena · Brief 2

I want my car to feel luxurious.

## The brief

- **Customer:** Neha recently gave a coworker a lift in her carefully cleaned hatchback. She wished the cabin felt more luxurious and has since started comparing car perfumes online.
- **Who:** Woman, 30–36, living in a tier-two Indian city. Drives a Hyundai Grand i10. Her partner rides on weekends; a coworker occasionally joins her commute.
- **Feels:** She feels proud of owning her car and wants its interior to reflect her taste.
- **Habit:** She tidies the cabin before office trips and saves car fragrance options to compare after work.
- **Awareness stage:** 3 - solution-aware
- **Main doubt:** I can't smell it before buying.
- **Job of the ad:** earn the click
- **Placement:** cold traffic; Instagram and Facebook Reels, 9:16
- **Format:** Creator talking to the phone camera from the driver's seat of their own parked car. No passenger required.
- **Production:** One creator, a phone, their own car, at most one passenger on screen. No studio, no stock footage.
- **Length:** 30 seconds, 66-90 spoken words, 4-7 beats
- **Scent:** Oud
- **Offer:** Buy 2, get 1 free
- **Call to action:** noirdrive.example, soft close
- **Concept:** For a small-car owner who wants a more luxurious cabin and is comparing car fragrance options. Make Noir Drive worth exploring on noirdrive.example. The writer chooses the angle, hook, proof and copy.
- **Brief hypothesis:** If the ad makes Noir Drive relevant to her search for a more luxurious cabin, then the outbound click-through rate will increase, because she already wants a car fragrance but has not chosen a brand.

## Scripts

Ordered by win rate on this brief. Every verdict is in data.json.

### Claude Opus 5.5: Make the i10 Smell Expensive: Oud

Win rate on this brief: 91% of 78 judgments · 90 spoken words (target 66–90, in range) · gate failures: allowed claims 5

**0-4s**  
Spoken: You cleaned your car for that office drop, and it still smelled like nothing.  
Shot: Creator in the driver's seat of her parked, spotless hatchback. Close framing, natural daylight. She glances at the empty passenger seat, then back at the camera.  
Text on screen: Clean car. Zero luxury.  

**4-10s**  
Spoken: I wanted my i10 to feel expensive. So I tried a car perfume, not a freshener. This is Oud from Noir Drive.  
Shot: She lifts the Noir Drive Oud bottle into frame, holding it beside her face. The label is readable.  
Text on screen: Car PERFUME, not freshener  

**10-17s**  
Spoken: Two sprays on the seat fabric, and it smells like a five-star hotel lobby. Warm, woody, calm.  
Shot: She turns and sprays twice on the seat fabric, then once on the hanging tag. She closes her eyes for a beat and smiles.  
Text on screen: Spray on fabric, not air  

**17-23s**  
Spoken: Can't smell it online? Fair. Over a million cars use it, with fifty thousand plus reviews.  
Shot: Back to the camera. She shrugs, as if acknowledging a fair point.  
Text on screen: 1 million+ cars · 50,000+ reviews  

**23-30s**  
Spoken: It's buy two, get one free, so pick Oud and two more to try. Have a look at noirdrive.example.  
Shot: She holds the bottle up and taps it lightly, relaxed and smiling. noirdrive.example appears at the bottom of the frame.  
Text on screen: Buy 2, Get 1 Free · noirdrive.example  

- **Primary text:** Make your hatchback smell like a hotel lobby. Oud car perfume. Buy 2, get 1 free at noirdrive.example
- **Headline:** Oud Car Perfume: Buy 2, Get 1 Free
- **Writer's hypothesis** (the judges do not see it): This ad will work for Neha because it shows her small car smelling luxurious and answers her 'can't smell it' doubt with scale proof and a 3-scent offer.

### Gemini 4 Argon: $12,000 car, $71,000 cabin — Oud

Win rate on this brief: 83% of 78 judgments · 95 spoken words (target 66–90, within 15%) · gate failures: none

**0-5s**  
Spoken: You can clean a hatchback all Sunday, and it still won't feel like a luxury cabin.  
Shot: Creator (woman, early 30s) in the driver's seat of a clean parked hatchback, speaking to phone camera on the dash.  
Text on screen: Clean car ≠ luxury cabin  

**5-11s**  
Spoken: That's because regular hanging fresheners use about two percent fragrance oil. Noir Drive uses twenty to thirty percent European fragrance oil.  
Shot: She gestures to the AC vent, then holds up the 30 ml Noir Drive Oud bottle.  
Text on screen: 2% oil vs 20–30% European fragrance oil  

**11-17s**  
Spoken: It's an alcohol-free car perfume you spray on the hanging tag and your fabric seats.  
Shot: She sprays twice onto the hanging diffuser tag and once onto the fabric passenger seat.  
Text on screen: Alcohol-free • Spray on tag & seats  

**17-24s**  
Spoken: And if you're nervous buying online without smelling it first, Oud smells like walking into a five-star hotel lobby.  
Shot: Close-up of the Oud bottle label, then back to her face as she takes a gentle breath.  
Text on screen: Oud = 5-star hotel lobby  

**24-30s**  
Spoken: Used in over a million cars. Right now it's buy two, get one free on noirdrive.example if you want to look.  
Shot: She rests the bottle in the console cupholder and smiles warmly at the camera.  
Text on screen: 1 million+ cars • Buy 2 Get 1 Free • noirdrive.example  

- **Primary text:** Want your cabin to feel like a 5-star hotel lobby? 20–30% European fragrance oil. Buy 2, get 1 free at noirdrive.example.
- **Headline:** Luxury Car Perfume — Buy 2 Get 1 Free
- **Writer's hypothesis** (the judges do not see it): This ad will work for her because it contrasts 20-30% European fragrance oil with 2% fresheners to justify the luxury upgrade, while translating Oud into a familiar 'five-star hotel lobby' scent so she feels safe clicking without smelling it first.

### DeepSeek V4 Pro: Small car, luxury cabin

Win rate on this brief: 74% of 78 judgments · 81 spoken words (target 66–90, in range) · gate failures: allowed claims 2

**0-3s**  
Spoken: My car is spotless, but it never felt premium.  
Shot: Creator in the driver's seat of a clean hatchback, talking to the phone camera.  
Text on screen: Small car, big taste  

**3-8s**  
Spoken: I wanted a cabin that feels luxurious, not just clean.  
Shot: She glances at the dashboard and seat, then back to the camera.  
Text on screen: Not just clean  

**8-16s**  
Spoken: This is Noir Drive Oud. One spray on the seat, and it smells rich—like a five-star lobby.  
Shot: She picks up a Noir Drive Oud bottle and sprays once on the seat fabric.  
Text on screen: Noir Drive Oud  

**16-22s**  
Spoken: Most fresheners fade in days. This HeatLock formula lasts months, because it isn't alcohol-based.  
Shot: Close-up of the bottle and diffuser tag; she gestures to the tag.  
Text on screen: HeatLock formula · lasts months  

**22-28s**  
Spoken: I couldn't smell it before buying either. So I checked the 50,000 reviews. Now there's buy two, get one free.  
Shot: She looks into the camera and nods, as if sharing a tip.  
Text on screen: 50,000+ reviews · Buy 2, get 1 free  

**28-30s**  
Spoken: Oud from Noir Drive, on noirdrive.example.  
Shot: She smiles and points subtly toward the camera, still parked.  
Text on screen: noirdrive.example  

- **Primary text:** Small car? Make the cabin feel luxury. Noir Drive Oud lasts months, not days. Buy 2, get 1 free at noirdrive.example
- **Headline:** Oud that lasts months
- **Writer's hypothesis** (the judges do not see it): This ad will work for this person because it frames Noir Drive Oud as the long-lasting luxury upgrade for her small car and answers the 'can't smell it before buying' objection with 50,000 reviews.

### MiMo V2.6 Pro: Hatchback to hotel lobby (Oud)

Win rate on this brief: 62% of 77 judgments · 95 spoken words (target 66–90, within 15%) · gate failures: allowed claims 9; follows the brief 10; holds together 5

**0-4s**  
Spoken: I love my hatchback. But when someone gets in, I want it to feel premium, not just clean.  
Shot: Creator in driver's seat of her parked, spotless hatchback. Camera steady on her face, dashboard and seat visible.  
Text on screen: The one thing my car was missing  

**4-10s**  
Spoken: Gels and hanging fresheners faded in days. Noir Drive is 20 to 30% designer-grade European fragrance oil.  
Shot: She glances at a dangling freshener on the mirror, unhooks it, holds it up to camera then sets it aside.  
Text on screen: Most fresheners: ~2% fragrance oil  

**10-17s**  
Spoken: Two sprays on the seats and mats. Oud soaks into the fabric — it smells like a five-star hotel lobby.  
Shot: She sprays the seat fabric and mats, leans back as if breathing it in, calm and satisfied.  
Text on screen: Oud. Spray the fabric, not the air.  

**17-23s**  
Spoken: The HeatLock formula holds up to a parked car's heat. The scent lasts two to three months.  
Shot: She taps the sunlit dashboard; cut to her closing the door in the heat.  
Text on screen: 188° slow-evaporation formula  

**23-26s**  
Spoken: A million cars. Fifty thousand reviews.  
Shot: She looks straight into the lens, confident, no cutaways.  
Text on screen: 10,00,000+ cars · 50,000+ reviews  

**26-30s**  
Spoken: Can't smell it first? Try the discovery set. Buy two, get one free at noirdrive.example.  
Shot: She holds the bottle and the diffuser tag toward the lens, then points down toward the profile link.  
Text on screen: noirdrive.example · Buy 2, get 1 free  

- **Primary text:** Your cabin, but luxurious. Oud car perfume that lasts months — not days. Buy 2, get 1 free → noirdrive.example
- **Headline:** Make your cabin smell like $70,000
- **Writer's hypothesis** (the judges do not see it): This ad will work for her because it names the upgrade she wants — a cabin that smells expensive — and answers her "can't smell it first" objection with a discovery set, giving her a reason to click now.

### Muse Wonder: Small Car, Luxurious Cabin

Win rate on this brief: 58% of 77 judgments · 88 spoken words (target 66–90, in range) · gate failures: allowed claims 2; holds together 4

**0-3s**  
Spoken: I cleaned my whole car, but it still didn't feel... luxurious.  
Shot: Creator in the driver's seat of her parked small car, gesturing at the clean cabin  
Text on screen: Clean, but not luxurious?  

**3-9s**  
Spoken: So I compared those hanging fresheners — most are about 2% fragrance oil and fade in days.  
Shot: She holds up a typical hanging freshener, then puts it aside  
Text on screen: Typical freshener: ~2% fragrance oil  

**9-17s**  
Spoken: This is Noir Drive Oud. It uses 20 to 30% European fragrance oil, so two sprays on the tag and seats feel rich, warm, premium.  
Shot: She shows the Noir Drive Oud bottle, sprays twice onto the diffuser tag and once toward the seat fabric  
Text on screen: Noir Drive Oud: 20-30% fragrance oil  

**17-24s**  
Spoken: Its HeatLock formula is made to last — one bottle goes two to three months. Over a million cars use it.  
Shot: Close-up of her hanging the sprayed tag, then back to her talking to camera  
Text on screen: HeatLock formula • 2-3 months per bottle  

**24-30s**  
Spoken: Nervous buying unsmelled? I checked fifty thousand reviews. Buy two, get one free at noirdrive.example.  
Shot: She smiles, holds the bottle beside the hanging tag as the cabin shot lingers  
Text on screen: Buy 2, Get 1 Free • noirdrive.example  

- **Primary text:** Your small car can feel luxurious. Noir Drive Oud, made to last months — not days.
- **Headline:** Buy 2, Get 1 Free on Oud
- **Writer's hypothesis** (the judges do not see it): This ad will work for this person because it turns her saved fragrance comparison into a concrete luxury upgrade, with proof and reviews reducing the can't-smell-it risk.

### Kimi K3.1 Pro: Clean Isn't Luxurious

Win rate on this brief: 55% of 78 judgments · 90 spoken words (target 66–90, in range) · gate failures: allowed claims 8; follows the brief 15

**0-3s**  
Spoken: A spotless car still might not feel luxurious.  
Shot: Creator talks to the phone from the driver's seat of her parked hatchback, then glances around the tidy cabin.  
Text on screen: Clean ≠ luxurious  

**3-7s**  
Spoken: I realised that when a coworker got into my little hatchback.  
Shot: She stays on camera, gesturing toward the empty passenger seat.  

**7-13s**  
Spoken: If you're comparing car perfumes, explore Noir Drive Oud—think five-star hotel lobby.  
Shot: She picks up the Noir Drive bottle and diffuser tag, keeping her face in frame.  
Text on screen: Noir Drive Oud  

**13-20s**  
Spoken: It has 20–30% European fragrance oil, and its HeatLock formula means a bottle lasts two to three months with normal use.  
Shot: Close-up of her spraying the seat fabric, followed by the bottle in her hand.  
Text on screen: 20–30% fragrance oil • HeatLock formula  

**20-26s**  
Spoken: Spray the fabric or diffuser tag. Can't smell it online? Fair. You can start with the four-sample discovery set instead.  
Shot: She sprays the diffuser tag, then looks back into the camera.  
Text on screen: Prefer to sample first?  

**26-30s**  
Spoken: Oud is $11, with buy two, get one free. Explore it at noirdrive.example.  
Shot: She holds the bottle beside the tag and gives a relaxed nod toward the website text.  
Text on screen: $11 • Buy 2, Get 1 Free
noirdrive.example  

- **Primary text:** Make your cabin feel more luxurious. Explore Noir Drive Oud at noirdrive.example. Buy 2, get 1 free.
- **Headline:** A More Luxurious Cabin, In Oud
- **Writer's hypothesis** (the judges do not see it): This ad will work for her because it connects Oud to the luxurious cabin she already wants, substantiates quality and longevity, and honestly offers a sampling route for her online-scent hesitation.

### GPT-6 Astra: Small Car, Hotel-Lobby Feeling

Win rate on this brief: 55% of 78 judgments · 69 spoken words (target 66–90, in range) · gate failures: none

**0-4s**  
Spoken: Love your little car, but want that five-star hotel feeling inside?  
Shot: Creator speaks to the phone camera from the driver's seat of her parked hatchback.  
Text on screen: Your car. A little more luxury.  

**4-9s**  
Spoken: If you're comparing car perfumes, put Noir Drive Oud on your shortlist.  
Shot: She gestures toward the tidy cabin, then holds the Oud bottle beside her face.  
Text on screen: Noir Drive • Oud  

**9-14s**  
Spoken: Spray the tag. It absorbs the perfume and keeps releasing the scent.  
Shot: Cut to a close phone shot of her spraying the diffuser tag.  
Text on screen: Spray the tag  

**14-20s**  
Spoken: Can you smell it through this screen? No. Scent is personal.  
Shot: Return to her face. She holds the tag loosely and speaks directly to camera.  

**20-25s**  
Spoken: But a brand used in over a million cars? Worth a look.  
Shot: She places the bottle in the foreground, with the clean cabin visible behind it.  
Text on screen: Used in 1 million+ cars  

**25-30s**  
Spoken: Explore Oud at noirdrive.example. Buy two, get one free.  
Shot: She holds the Oud bottle beside her face for a relaxed close.  
Text on screen: noirdrive.example
Buy 2, get 1 free  

- **Primary text:** A little luxury for the car you love. Explore Noir Drive Oud. Buy 2, get 1 free.
- **Headline:** Put Oud on your shortlist
- **Writer's hypothesis** (the judges do not see it): This ad will work for this person because it connects Oud to her cabin upgrade and gives her a credible reason to explore despite not being able to smell it.

### GPT-6.1 Sol: Small Car, Luxurious Cabin

Win rate on this brief: 47% of 77 judgments · 73 spoken words (target 66–90, in range) · gate failures: follows the brief 4

**0-4s**  
Spoken: A small car can still feel luxurious. Scent makes a difference.  
Shot: Creator speaks to the phone camera from the driver's seat of her parked hatchback.  
Text on screen: Love your car. Upgrade the scent.  

**4-10s**  
Spoken: If a five-star hotel lobby is your idea of luxury, consider Noir Drive Oud.  
Shot: Creator holds the Oud bottle beside her face, with the label visible.  
Text on screen: Noir Drive • Oud  

**10-15s**  
Spoken: Spray the tag. It absorbs the perfume and keeps releasing scent.  
Shot: Close phone shot of the creator spraying the diffuser tag, then hanging it.  
Text on screen: 20–30% designer-grade European fragrance oil  

**15-19s**  
Spoken: Choosing a scent online is hard. You can't smell the screen.  
Shot: Return to the creator speaking directly to the camera.  

**19-25s**  
Spoken: There's a discovery set: four sample sprays, so you can compare scents in your car.  
Shot: Creator holds the bottle while speaking. Keep the clean cabin visible.  
Text on screen: Discovery set • Four 10 ml sprays • $14  

**25-30s**  
Spoken: Explore Oud at noirdrive.example. Buy two, get one free.  
Shot: Creator sets the bottle beside the hanging tag. Finish on a simple phone shot of both.  
Text on screen: noirdrive.example
Buy 2, get 1 free  

- **Primary text:** Give your cabin a touch of luxury. Explore Noir Drive Oud and the discovery set at noirdrive.example.
- **Headline:** Explore Oud for your car
- **Writer's hypothesis** (the judges do not see it): This ad will work for this person because it connects scent to cabin luxury and offers a way to compare scents in her own car.

### Grok 4.7: Oud for a more luxurious cabin

Win rate on this brief: 46% of 78 judgments · 92 spoken words (target 66–90, within 15%) · gate failures: none

**0-4s**  
Spoken: I tidy this hatchback before office trips. I still wanted the cabin to feel luxurious.  
Shot: Creator in the driver's seat of a parked hatchback, phone camera, cabin tidy  
Text on screen: A more luxurious cabin  

**4-9s**  
Spoken: So I tried Oud from Noir Drive. It's a car perfume, not another hanging gel.  
Shot: She holds up the Noir Drive Oud bottle and hanging tag  
Text on screen: Oud car perfume  

**9-16s**  
Spoken: Twenty to thirty percent European fragrance oil. The HeatLock formula is sprayed on the seats and the tag, so the scent soaks into the fabric.  
Shot: Close on a light spray into the seat fabric, then the tag hung from the mirror  
Text on screen: Spray fabric, not just air  

**16-23s**  
Spoken: I couldn't smell it before buying either. It's already in a million cars, with fifty thousand reviews.  
Shot: Back to her face, parked car, no passenger  
Text on screen: 1 million+ cars  

**23-30s**  
Spoken: Buy two, get one free on noirdrive.example. If you want the cabin to feel luxurious, start with Oud.  
Shot: Bottle and tag in frame, she glances at the cabin, then back to camera  
Text on screen: Buy 2, get 1 free  

- **Primary text:** Oud for a more luxurious cabin. Buy 2, get 1 free at noirdrive.example.
- **Headline:** Start with Oud
- **Writer's hypothesis** (the judges do not see it): This ad will work for this person because she already wants a luxurious cabin and a car fragrance, and the script makes Oud the option worth opening by naming the oil, fabric use, and review proof she can check before she can smell it.

### Claude Fable 5.1: Small car, big-car smell

Win rate on this brief: 38% of 77 judgments · 97 spoken words (target 66–90, within 15%) · gate failures: allowed claims 42; holds together 6

**0-3s**  
Spoken: If you've been comparing car perfumes to make your small car feel more expensive, this is the one I'd try first.  
Shot: Creator in driver's seat of a clean hatchback, phone propped on dash, looks straight into camera.  
Text on screen: Comparing car perfumes?  

**3-10s**  
Spoken: Hanging fresheners use about two percent fragrance oil. Noir Drive uses twenty to thirty. That's why it smells like a five-star lobby, not a cab.  
Shot: Holds up the Noir Drive Oud bottle and diffuser tag, taps the hanging freshener on the mirror.  
Text on screen: 2% oil vs 20–30%  

**10-18s**  
Spoken: This is Oud. Sprayed on the fabric it keeps releasing for days, and one bottle lasts two to three months.  
Shot: Sprays twice on the tag and once on the seat fabric, breathes in, small smile.  
Text on screen: Oud · lasts months, not days  

**18-25s**  
Spoken: Can't smell it through a screen, I know. That's why fifty thousand reviews matter more than my opinion.  
Shot: Leans back, hands bottle toward camera, casual.  
Text on screen: 50,000+ reviews · 1 million+ cars  

**25-30s**  
Spoken: Buy two, get one free on noirdrive.example. Go have a look.  
Shot: Hangs the tag on the mirror, glances at camera.  
Text on screen: noirdrive.example · Buy 2, get 1 free  

- **Primary text:** Comparing car perfumes? 20–30% fragrance oil, lasts months. Oud. 50,000+ reviews. Buy 2, get 1 free.
- **Headline:** Make a small car smell expensive
- **Writer's hypothesis** (the judges do not see it): This ad will work for Neha because it meets her mid-comparison, gives one concrete fact that separates Noir Drive from the fresheners she's weighing, answers the can't-smell-it doubt with review volume, and asks only for a look.

### Qwen 3.8 Max: The coworker compliment that started it

Win rate on this brief: 14% of 78 judgments · 90 spoken words (target 66–90, in range) · gate failures: allowed claims 60; holds together 5

**0-3s**  
Spoken: My coworker got in last week and said, 'Your car smells like a luxury sedan.'  
Shot: Creator sits in driver's seat of a parked hatchback, phone propped on dashboard, talking directly to camera.  

**3-8s**  
Spoken: It's a Grand i10. I just started using this.  
Shot: Same framing, creator leans in slightly, conspiratorial tone.  

**8-14s**  
Spoken: Noir Drive. Oud. Twenty to thirty percent European fragrance oil sprayed straight onto the fabric tag.  
Shot: Creator holds up the Noir Drive bottle briefly, then sprays it once on the hanging diffuser tag near the rearview mirror.  
Text on screen: 20–30% fragrance oil  

**14-20s**  
Spoken: Most fresheners are two percent and fade in days because alcohol evaporates at seventy-eight degrees. This formula holds up to a hundred and eighty-eight.  
Shot: Creator sets the bottle down, gestures at the cabin around her.  
Text on screen: HeatLock formula — built for Indian summers  

**20-26s**  
Spoken: One bottle lasts two to three months. That's about two cents a spray.  
Shot: Creator picks up the bottle again, looks at camera with a small knowing smile.  
Text on screen: 2¢ per spray · lasts 2–3 months  

**26-30s**  
Spoken: Buy two, get one free right now. Link's noirdrive.example.  
Shot: Creator sprays once more on the tag, sets it back, glances at camera.  
Text on screen: Buy 2 Get 1 Free → noirdrive.example  

- **Primary text:** She drives a Grand i10. People think it's a luxury sedan. The secret is one spray on a fabric tag.
- **Headline:** Your hatchback deserves this
- **Writer's hypothesis** (the judges do not see it): This ad will work for Neha because it mirrors her exact situation—a small-car owner who wants the cabin to feel premium—and reframes Noir Drive as the shortcut she's already searching for, using a peer's compliment as social proof and the HeatLock formula as a concrete differentiator from the gels and hanging fresheners she's been comparing.

### Mistral Small 3: Luxurious Car Cabin with Noir Drive

Win rate on this brief: 8% of 75 judgments · 85 spoken words (target 66–90, in range) · gate failures: allowed claims 53; follows the brief 41; holds together 1; can be shot 2

**0-3s**  
Spoken: Ever wished your car felt more luxurious?  
Shot: Creator sitting in the driver's seat of their car, smiling  

**3-6s**  
Spoken: Introducing Noir Drive, a luxury car perfume that lasts up to 3 months.  
Shot: Creator spraying Noir Drive on the car seats  

**6-9s**  
Spoken: With our HeatLock formula, it soaks into your fabric and keeps releasing scent.  
Shot: Creator showing the Noir Drive bottle and diffuser tag  

**9-12s**  
Spoken: No more harsh chemicals, just a premium, long-lasting fragrance.  
Shot: Creator enjoying the scent, looking pleased  

**12-15s**  
Spoken: Try Oud, our best-selling scent. Buy 2, get 1 free.  
Shot: Creator holding the Noir Drive bottle  

**15-18s**  
Spoken: Elevate your driving experience with Noir Drive.  
Shot: Creator smiling and giving a thumbs up  

**18-21s**  
Spoken: Visit noirdrive.example to explore our scents.  
Shot: Creator holding the Noir Drive bottle  

**21-24s**  
Spoken: Transform your car into a luxurious sanctuary.  
Shot: Creator spraying Noir Drive on the car seats  

**24-27s**  
Spoken: Noir Drive: because your car deserves the best.  
Shot: Creator enjoying the scent, looking pleased  

**27-30s**  
Spoken: noirdrive.example  
Shot: Creator giving a thumbs up, Noir Drive logo on screen  
Text on screen: Noir Drive  

- **Primary text:** Transform your car into a luxurious sanctuary with Noir Drive. Try Oud, our best-selling scent. Buy 2, get 1 free.
- **Headline:** Elevate Your Driving Experience
- **Writer's hypothesis** (the judges do not see it): This ad will work for Neha because it directly addresses her desire for a more luxurious car cabin and offers a premium, long-lasting fragrance solution.

### Llama 3.1 70B: Luxury in Every Drive

Win rate on this brief: 8% of 78 judgments · 82 spoken words (target 66–90, in range) · gate failures: allowed claims 3; follows the brief 5; can be shot 34

**0-3s**  
Spoken: Hey there, fellow car lovers!  
Shot: Creator sitting in the driver's seat of their car, smiling at the camera  

**4-6s**  
Spoken: I recently discovered Noir Drive, and it's been a game-changer for my daily drives.  
Shot: Creator holding up a Noir Drive perfume bottle  

**7-10s**  
Spoken: Their Oud scent is amazing - it's like having a luxurious spa experience in my car!  
Shot: Creator spraying the perfume into the air and taking a sniff  

**11-14s**  
Spoken: And the best part? It's long-lasting, so I don't have to worry about the scent fading away.  
Shot: Creator holding up the perfume bottle again, with the Noir Drive logo visible  
Text on screen: HeatLock formula for Long-Lasting Fragrance  

**15-18s**  
Spoken: Want to elevate your daily drives? Try Noir Drive today!  
Shot: Creator smiling at the camera, with the car's interior visible behind them  
Text on screen: Buy 2, Get 1 Free | noirdrive.example  

**19-30s**  
Spoken: Head to noirdrive.example to explore their range of scents and get ready to experience luxury in every drive!  
Shot: Creator holding up their phone with the Noir Drive website on the screen  

- **Primary text:** Luxury Car Perfume | Long-Lasting Fragrance
- **Headline:** Elevate Your Drives with Noir Drive
- **Writer's hypothesis** (the judges do not see it): This ad will work for Neha because it showcases a relatable scenario, highlights the benefits of the product, and provides a clear call-to-action, making her more likely to click and explore the website.

### GLM-5.3 Prime: Oud makes a Grand i10 feel like a luxury cabin

Win rate on this brief: 0% of 75 judgments · 119 spoken words (target 66–90, out of range) · gate failures: allowed claims 4; follows the brief 75; holds together 14

**0-3s**  
Spoken: I love my Grand i10. But a clean car is not the same as a luxury car.  
Shot: Creator in driver's seat, parked, holding phone; looks into camera  

**3-8s**  
Spoken: The difference? The smell. Step into a five-star lobby and it hits you instantly.  
Shot: Creator runs hand over dashboard and seat fabric  
Text on screen: Luxury is a smell  

**8-15s**  
Spoken: So I spray Noir Drive Oud on my seats and this hanging tag. It's 20 to 30 percent European fragrance oil, nose-tested. Most hanging fresheners have about 2 percent.  
Shot: Creator holds up Noir Drive bottle, sprays twice onto seat fabric and the hanging tag  
Text on screen: 20-30% fragrance oil  

**15-22s**  
Spoken: It's alcohol-free, and the HeatLock formula doesn't fade in parked-car heat, so it lasts months, not days.  
Shot: Creator closes eyes briefly, inhales, smiles  
Text on screen: Lasts months, not days  

**22-27s**  
Spoken: Now when a coworker gets in, my car smells like it costs twelve thousand dollars more than it did.  
Shot: Creator gestures to cabin around them  
Text on screen: A $12,000 car can smell like $70,000  

**27-30s**  
Spoken: Worried you can't smell it first? Right now it's buy two, get one free. Find it at noirdrive.example.  
Shot: Creator shrugs warmly, holds up bottle toward camera  
Text on screen: Buy 2, Get 1 Free · noirdrive.example  

- **Primary text:** Turn your cabin into the luxury car you already love. Oud, 20-30% European fragrance oil, alcohol-free. Buy 2, get 1 free at noirdrive.example.
- **Headline:** Noir Drive Oud · Buy 2 Get 1 Free
- **Writer's hypothesis** (the judges do not see it): She already wants a fragrance for a more luxurious cabin, so showing Oud as the one upgrade that makes her small car smell premium, plus a risk-lowering free-bottle offer, earns the outbound click.

